The Comparison Between Puritan Colonies and Other Religions in the Massachusetts Bay Colony

What characterized the comparison between Puritan colonies and other religions in the Massachusetts Bay Colony (MBC)?

a) The Puritans were the only religious group in MBC.
b) The Puritans coexisted peacefully with other religious communities.
c) The Puritans allowed complete religious freedom for all in MBC.
d) The Puritans held a dominant position, limiting religious tolerance for others.

Final answer:

The Puritans in the Massachusetts Bay Colony held a dominant position and limited religious tolerance for other groups, not practicing religious freedom for all.

The comparison between Puritan colonies and other religious groups in the Massachusetts Bay Colony (MBC) is best characterized by the fact that the Puritans held a dominant position, limiting religious tolerance for others. This is evidenced by historical events where dissenters like Anne Hutchinson and Roger Williams were exiled for their religious beliefs, and the infamous 1692 Salem witch trials, which saw executions based on accusations of witchcraft. The Puritans intended to reform the Church of England rather than separate from it, setting an example for the Anglican Church to follow, which distinguished them from the Pilgrims of Plymouth who preferred to separate entirely.